MEPS Medical Error

Comment

Comment by Bill Tucker on July 7, 2016 at 12:29pm

Final Status Update: The Navy basically "Tough Luck Sailor".  They did not accept our doctor's evaluation.  Not really surprising.  But...I have a way around the system by using the system.  After she gets deployed, she could find an excuse for the Navy doctor to examine her eyes, new prescription, broken glasses, or whatever.  She would then be able to take the eye test to validate the new prescription or whatever and that would then become part of her record.  Assuming that she does evaluate as 20/20 and normal depth perception as our doc said, I would think that she could then ask to be reclassified as an MA.  Or another Rate that has those same requirements if she chooses.

Comment by Bill Tucker on July 2, 2016 at 9:57am

Thanks Paul and Jim.

I'll keep pushing.

No stone left unturned.

Comment by NavyDads Admin (Paul) on July 2, 2016 at 8:32am

If the recruiter in charge does not handle it, you need to ask for the Zone Supervisor, if nothing happens there, the next one you should ask and speak to is the Assistant Chief Recruiter, then the Chief Recruiter. IF all that fails, then my next step would be to contact the Commanding Officer. I would wait no more than 1-2 days between contacts (ZS, ACR, CR).
I can tell you that the last thing a recruiter wants (or needs) is negative attention.

Comment by NavyDads CoAdmin Jim Gramza on July 2, 2016 at 8:25am

I find this interesting. This is a link where we get our information about all the ratings. This information rating card was updated February of this year. It makes no reference like it used to concerning vision requirements.

http://www.cool.navy.mil/usn/enlisted/rating_info_cards/ma.pdf

Comment by Bill Tucker on July 1, 2016 at 10:53pm

Well, we finally got something back from our recruiter.  He said that they said that they did not see any difference in her depth perception and that still disqualifies her from being an MA.  Though he did not explicitly say that they accepted or rejected the doctors report on her eyes being correctable to 20/20 he talked only of the depth perception disqualification.  Looking at all the information that i have available, bad depth perception is not disqualifying.  Only color perception  and 20/20 correction are the requirements.  For me, depth perception would be important for a cop.  But not in the requirements that i can find.  Even on this site the requirements are exactly what i find on http://www.public.navy.mil/bupers-npc/enlisted/community/security/P...

Does anyone know of anything different?

I will be checking in with her recruiter on Tuesday after the holiday.

Comment by Navy Dads Co-Admin Tom on June 10, 2016 at 8:46pm

1....Yes...Always need women

2.....MA's....not so much...no leverage there

3.....She is under NO obligation at this point...If it is not what she wants....walk on....

Comment by Bill Tucker on June 10, 2016 at 3:08pm

That's what we're hoping for.
One of the ways we're looking at is...
You need females,

You need MA's

You screwed up

Do right by our daughter or she walks.

Comment by Navy Dads Co-Admin Tom on June 10, 2016 at 12:00pm

 I would guess that her best bet is to have the Recruiter push for a retest. With the supporting report, she might just pull it off!